In his church, not a trace
Of a soul in the place,
So down to the beach
Went St Anthony to preach.
The fish were excited,
Their scales sun-ignited.
The carp full of roe
Soon gathered below;
Mouths open, they stare
As they listen with care.
No sermon before
Had brought them to the shore.
The sharp-snouted pike
Always up for a fight
Very promptly bestirred
To hear the good word.
Even those strange fish
That never seem peckish
(I’m meaning the cod)
Want to hear about God.
No sermon before
Brought those stockfish to shore.
Good eels and sturgeon
Which aristos gorge on,
Even they condescend
The address to attend.
Also turtles and crayfish,
Habitually sluggish,
Rush up and rejoice
To hear the priest’s voice.
This sermon indeed
Caused the crayfish to speed!
Big fish and small
Lords, peasants and all
Each raising his head
As to cognisance bred.
As was God’s intention,
They paid close attention.
The sermon now ended
Each turned and descended.
The pikes still would quarrel,
Eels still were immoral.
A sermon though nice is
No cure for their vices.
Back down go the crayfish
Still plump are the stockfish.
The carp eat a lot ‘n’
The sermon’s forgotten!
A sermon might move them
But never improve them!
Das Knaben Wunderhorn, ed. Armin & Brentano, 1808. Translated by Chris Short.
Refer to: 2019 meetings
My translation adheres to the rhyme and metre of the original.
Wow! love “The carp eat a lot’n” Can an eel be immoral?
St Anthony evidently thought that they would benefit from moral instruction…